Welcome to Crappie Shop
At Crappie Shop, nestled in Arena, Wisconsin, we have crafted a culinary haven that brings the community together. Our story begins with a commitment to exceptional food, highlighted by our mouthwatering subs, specialty pizzas like the savory Meat Lovers and tangy Pickle Ranch, and a famous Friday Fish Fry. Each dish is made with fresh ingredients, served by our friendly staff who prioritize an inviting atmosphere. Beyond food, we support our local fire department and provide convenience items, making us a versatile stop. At Crappie Shop, you're not just dining; you're part of our family. Come savor the love!
- 300 Dalogasa Dr, Arena, WI 53503, United States Hotline: +1 608-753-2727
Welcome to Crappie Shop, a gem nestled at 300 Dalogasa Dr, Arena, WI 53503, where food lovers unite in a friendly atmosphere that feels like home. This multifunctional spot is not just another eatery; it's a lively community hub that serves up mouthwatering dishes alongside a quaint convenience store. With a dedicated phone line at +1 608-753-2727, you're never far from deliciousness!
At Crappie Shop, the culinary offerings are diverse and impactful. Their specialty pizzas are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Whether you’re a fan of the bold 16 Pickle Ranch Pizza topped with thick dill pickles and ranch dressing ($14.99) or crave the hearty Meat Lovers loaded with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and ham ($20.99), there's something for everyone. Other crowd-pleasers include the Chicken Bacon Ranch and the vibrant Supreme, each bursting with flavor and made fresh to order.
- 16 Pickle Ranch Pizza - $14.99
- 16 Hawaiian - $17.99
- 16 Chicken Bacon Ranch - $18.99
- 16 Meat Lovers - $20.99
- 16 Chicken BBQ - $16.99
- 16 Supreme - $22.99
But pizza isn’t the only star at Crappie Shop. The selection of hot or cold subs is nothing short of stellar. Options like the Turkey Sub and the hearty Philly Cheese Steak cater to every palate. Additionally, the Italian Sub made with pepperoni, ham, and salami is a must-try for fans of classic sub sandwiches.
- Turkey Sub
- Grilled Chicken Sub
- Veggie Sub
- Philly Cheese Steak
- Cold Cut Sub
- Italian Sub
One of the standout features of Crappie Shop, as noted by satisfied patrons like Doug Anderson and Ashley Stammen, is the warmth of the staff. Guests frequently mention the friendly atmosphere and the eagerness of staff to ensure a great dining experience. Among the best-kept secrets here is the Friday Fish Fry, which has garnered rave reviews for its great flavor and delightful accompaniments, like crispy French fries and creamy coleslaw.
Furthermore, this establishment doesn’t solely focus on food. Crappie Shop also supports the local community, contributing to events and services such as the fire department. This commitment to community service paired with the friendly service is a recipe for success, as echoed by customers like Ethen Glasson.
In sum, Crappie Shop is more than just a dining location; it’s a celebration of food, community, and good times. Whether you're in the mood for pizza, subs, or a comforting dinner, every dish is crafted with care and meant to be shared in the company of friends and family. I wholeheartedly recommend that you pay a visit. You won’t leave disappointed!

Grate service food is amazing the atmosphere is loving and vary genuine for those who say otherwise Obviously haven't been there and anit eaten anything or even been In the store lovely place

I highly recommend this place they always have super friendly people on staff , Excellent Subs, Pizza and Friday Fish Fry that's great too. They also have a convenience store for beer soda, and basic stuff and to top it off to 5 stars they also have a small selection of ammunition !!

Great fish and pizza. They do a lot to support the fire department and community. Very nice people!

Always greeted by friendly staff. The good is great. Candy keeps the store full of all the necessities and has a huge variety. Stop in!

Very friendly!!! The cod dinner is delicious!! French fries are amazing!! Cole slaw tastes so good!!! Recommend you give it a try!!!!

The food is made fresh and is ready when I was told it would be! The owner and associate were very friendly and happy to visit with me. There are many food and beverages to choose from. It has a full liquor store. I order out frequently.

Such a wide variety of beers, wines and liquors! The food they offer is always great- we get the pizza a lot! And they've got a whole little grocery section for anything you might need last minute. Owners are fantastic people

It's walking distance, the staff is fun, it has enough food and ransoms for almost all random emergencies. Pizza and cooked food rocks and kids love the soft serve ice cream. We are still new to the community but really love our new local shop.