Crappie Shop Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to the Crappie Shop, a hidden gem nestled at 300 Dalogasa Dr, Arena, WI. This charming eatery is not just about food; it’s about community and warmth. Their menu brilliantly marries tradition with creativity, offering an array of hot and cold subs, including the hearty Italian Sausage Sub and the fresh Veggie Sub.
- Specialty Pizzas: Dive into their extraordinary options like the Pickle Ranch Pizza and Meat Lovers delight, both crowd favorites.
- Fresh Baked Pizza: Create your own pizza masterpiece with a variety of toppings for a fun, personalized dining experience.
- Friday Fish Fry: A local tradition that highlights their commitment to delicious, fresh seafood.
Customer reviews praise the genuine atmosphere, friendly staff, and the delicious food that draws everyone in. Whether for a quick bite or a cozy meal, Crappie Shop serves more than food—it serves a sense of belonging.
Specialty Pizza
16 Supreme
Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, mushrooms, green olive, black olives, onion and green peppers
16 Meat Lovers
Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham
16 Chicken Bacon Ranch
16 Chicken BBQ
16 Hawaiian
16 Pickle Ranch Pizza
Thick dill pickles on ranch dressing
16 Pizza-Create Your Own
Add all your favorite toppings.
12 Pizza-Create Your Own
Add all your favorite toppings.
7 Two Topping
Fresh Baked Pizza
Hot or Cold Subs
Italian Sub
Pepperoni, ham & salami
Cold Cut Sub
Ham, turkey & salami
Club
Turkey, ham & roast beef
BLT
Ham Sub
Roast Beef Sub
Turkey Sub
Veggie Sub
Pizza Sub
Pepperoni Sub
Italian Sausage Sub
Turkey Bacon Sub
Grilled Chicken Sub
Philly Cheese Steak
Hamburger
Ketchup, mustard, pickle
Double Hamburger
Ketchup, mustard, pickle
Cheese Burger
Cheese, ketchup, mustard, pickle
Bacon Cheese Burger
Bacon, ketchup, mustard, pickle
Crispy Chicken
Mayo, pickle
Fish Sandwich
Tartar, American cheese, pickle
Sandwiches
Chicken, Shrimp and Fish
Box Of Wings
21 pieces
Chicken Fries
8 pieces
Chicken Strips
4 pieces
Chicken Wings
10 pieces
Haddie (Haddock) Bites
12 pieces
21 Shrimp
Comes with cocktail sauce
French Fries
Sidewinders
Waffle Fries
Onion Rings
Onion Petals
Deep Fried Mushrooms
Pickle Chips-Thick Sliced
10 pieces
Jalapeno Poppers
6 pieces
Mini Corn Dogs
10 pieces
Mac & Cheese Wedges
10 pieces
Potato Cheddar Kegs
6 pieces
Broccoli & Cheese Bites
8 pieces
Cheese Curds
Mozzarella Sticks
6 pieces, comes with marinara
Mini Tacos
10 pieces, comes with sour cream and salsa
Sides
Dinners
Chicken Dinner
4 pieces
Shrimp Dinner
10 pieces, comes with cocktail sauce
Fish Dinner
3 pieces tavern battered, comes with tartar sauce
Deep Fried Beer Battered Cod
Fish Sandwich (2 Pieces 6 Oz) & Fries
Friday Fish Fry
Salads
Side Salad
Fresh garden mix topped with tomato and cheese.
Garden Salad
Fresh garden mix topped with green pepper, tomato and cheese.
Chef Salad
Fresh garden mix topped with ham, turkey, green pepper, tomato and cheese.
Grilled Chicken Salad
Fresh garden mix topped with grilled chicken, green pepper, tomato and cheese.